Reflection Questions
What prompts do you see Pat using to activate students prior knowledge about things in the storybook?
Pat elicits her student’s prior ideas about butterflies, problem solving, and insects.
- Pat gets her students to share what they know about butterflies by asking, “What do you think this story might be about?” (0:34)
- Prompting students to think of ways they might solve the problem Pat asks, “How could Mariana test to see if insects are coming to her flowers?” (4:04)
- Based on the insect unit they just completed, Pat asks, “Do insects have different types of mouth parts?” (5:00)
How does Pat use the actions of the character in the storybook to emphasize the Engineering Design Process (EDP)?
Rather than ask her students to think abstractly about steps in the design process, Pat grounds all of her questions in the storybook context.
- Referring to Mariana as an “engineer”, Pat asks, “What types of questions does Mariana need to think about before she can make her own hand pollinator?” (5:27)
- Pat creates an activity based on EDP {1-6}. She has groups match blue and white cards representing steps of the EDP with descriptions of what Mariana does in the book. (9:26)
- Pat grounds students’ definition of the EDP steps in Mariana’s process, “Who did Mariana ask?” (10:50) “What are some of the things she had to think about in the Imagine stage?” (11:03) “How did she Plan?” (11:31)
How does Pat adapt the lesson activities?
Pat makes modifications that help reduce the amount of writing required of her second graders She also makes the activities more appropriate for group work.
- Instead of having students work on their own to match jobs on the Pollination System {1-3}, Pat and students fill in a large Pollination System chart on the board as a group, enlarging the pictures and posting the matches. (7:05)
- Instead of writing on EDP {1-6}, Pat has kids work in groups to match cards of the EDP steps with Mariana’s actions in the book. (9:26)
- The guide recommends doing Pollination System {1-3} after reading Chapter 6, but Pat reads the entire book before conducting this activity. (7:05)
